This biography takes an interesting approach. The chapters alternate between history and musical analysis. So a chapter will detail Chopin's early life, and the next chapter will discuss his early compositions during that period. I think that's an effective approach - those readers who are not interested in detailed musical analysis can skip those chapters, and those readers who are interested in the music can use it as a reference.
Of course, no book on Chopin can succeed without dealing with the elephant in the room - his relationship with George Sand. I think this book does an excellent job of reporting the facts that can be verified about their life together without vilifying Sand or even placing blame. It's much better to report the facts and let the readers reach their own conclusion.
Now that I have read it I'll weigh in with my opinion, for what's it worth. Obviously they would not have stayed together as long as they did (9 years?) if each had not gotten something of value from the relationship. The fact that they were probably platonic after the second year means that it wasn't sex that keep them together. Sand mothered Chopin, and he let her. She provided stability and a place of refuge for him. She nursed him back to health several times. She also reinvented her past to suit her own purposes, probably to justify her own actions. Chopin seemed easily manipulated by Sand's daughter, who at least provided the immediate reason for the breakup.
But I don't think the facts, as presented in this book, support the idea that Chopin would have lived much longer and written more and better music if he had not lived with Sand. In my opinion the opposite is probably true. She provided some stability in his life during his most productive periods.
So read this biography and make up your own mind already!
Link to Amazon: Chopin (Master Musicians Series)
No comments:
Post a Comment