An Arsonist's Guide to Writers' Homes in New England by Brock Clarke

Great title, excellent idea, depressing execution. The mix of humor and tragedy is off. Too much tragedy, not enough humor, especially the ending.

The Lonely Polygamist by Brady Udall

An outstanding novel - if this doesn't win a major award this year I will be very surprised. It examines in detail a family of one husband, four wives, and twenty-eight or so children. The father is stretched too thin, economically and emotionally, and is lying to his wives and on the verge of having an affair - as odd as that may seem. Wife #4 and son #5 are followed closely as well, giving the reader a fascinating glimpse into the psychology of a poly-family.

But it is the humor that really makes the novel stand out. It's the humor of awkward situations and unintended consequences, the type where you just can't believe that happened, but are totally convinced it could have. The humor is mixed with pathos and tragedy, which makes it all the more real.

It's a fascinating novel, perfect for a book club or discussion group. A real page turner too, with unexpected twists and turns and an ending that is real and not manipulative or saccharine. Highly recommended.